What The Starling 20 in Tan Openweave actually is
The Starling 20 is a tailored loafer, and this version swaps the usual upper for openweave raffia — a material the catalog describes as handcrafted by artisans in Italy's Tuscan Hills. The looser weave and soft mesh lining are meant to create an airy, weightless feel for warmer months, while supple leather accents keep the silhouette looking polished rather than beachy.
That combination is the whole buying decision in a nutshell: you get a loafer shape with a breezy upper, but the structure and interior are still leather-based. If you want a warm-weather shoe that reads as a real loafer rather than a sandal, this is the pair to consider. If you need something you can wear in rain or slush, the openweave construction is working against you.
The catalog details that matter for your decision
- The Starling 20 - Tan Openweave: Openweave raffia upper handcrafted by artisans in Italy's Tuscan Hills, with a looser weave and soft mesh lining for an airy, weightless feel. This is the feature that defines the shoe. The open weave is what makes it a warm-weather loafer, and it also means the upper is more porous than a solid leather or suede style.

The Starling 20 - Tan Openweave - The Starling 20 - Tan Openweave: Supple leather accents maintain the silhouette's polished structure. Leather trim is what keeps the openweave from looking casual or flimsy. It also means part of the shoe needs leather-appropriate care, not just raffia care.
- The Starling 20 - Tan Openweave: Flex-Front Technology for maximum toe flexibility, a super soft leather interior with 7 layers of cloud-like comfort and full arch support. These are the comfort claims to weigh if you plan to wear the loafer for long days. The leather interior and arch support are the reasons this can pass as a comfortable everyday shoe rather than a special-occasion flat.
How the openweave changes the way you wear it
Openweave raffia is not a solid material, so treat this loafer as a dry-weather shoe. The catalog does not list any water-resistant or protective treatment, and the weave is intentionally loose. That does not mean the shoe is fragile — it means you should think about where you're going before you put it on. A garden lunch, an office day, or a city walk on a dry day is a natural fit. A commute through wet streets is not.
The mesh lining and looser weave also affect how the shoe feels against your foot. The catalog describes it as airy and weightless, which is the point of the openweave version. If you prefer a shoe that hugs the foot firmly, a solid leather or suede loafer will feel more substantial. If you overheat in closed shoes, this is the version that solves that problem.
Sizing and fit: what the catalog confirms
The Starling 20 in Tan Openweave comes in whole and half sizes from 5 through 10.5. That is the full extent of the sizing evidence supplied, and it is worth reading carefully before you order.
- Available sizes: Sizes 5, 5.5, 6, 6.5, 7, 7.5, 8, 8.5, 9, 9.5, 10 and 10.5 are listed. If you are outside that range, this particular style is not an option in the supplied catalog.
- Width: The supplied information does not list width options, so the Starling 20 appears to be offered in a single width. If you normally need a wide or narrow fit, that is a real limitation to weigh.
- How the openweave affects fit: The catalog does not state whether the openweave upper runs true to size or how much it stretches. Because the weave is looser than solid leather, some readers may wonder if it fits differently — but the supplied details do not confirm a sizing adjustment. Use your usual Starling or Birdies size as the starting point and check the retailer's exchange policy before ordering.
- What is not confirmed: There is no supplied guidance on break-in time, arch height beyond the full arch support claim, or whether the mesh lining changes the fit over months of wear. Those are questions to raise with customer service if they are decisive for you.
Who this loafer suits — and who should choose something else
The Starling 20 in Tan Openweave is a specific tool for a specific job. Here is the honest split.
- A good match if you want a warm-weather loafer that still looks polished: The openweave raffia and leather accents give you a breathable shoe that works with tailored trousers, midi skirts, or denim. The Flex-Front toe flexibility and leather interior support all-day wear in dry conditions.
- A good match if you like the Starling silhouette but overheat in closed shoes: The looser weave and mesh lining are the catalog's answer to warm-weather comfort. If you have avoided loafers in summer because they feel heavy, this is the version built to change that.
- Probably not the right pick if you need a rain-ready shoe: Openweave raffia is not a water-resistant material, and no protective treatment is listed. For wet commutes or unpredictable weather, a solid leather or suede loafer is the more practical choice.
- Probably not the right pick if you need a wide or narrow width: The supplied catalog lists sizes only, with no width options. If width is a dealbreaker, this style may not work for you.
Care expectations before you commit
The supplied product record does not include care instructions for this specific pair, so there is no manufacturer-approved cleaning routine to quote here. That is a limitation of the information, not a sign that the shoe is hard to care for. What the catalog does confirm is that the shoe combines raffia, mesh and leather — three materials with different needs. Raffia generally dislikes soaking, mesh is not built for heavy scrubbing, and leather accents need protection from prolonged moisture.
A reasonable approach is to keep the shoe dry, store it away from direct heat, and spot-clean only when necessary with a method appropriate to the material you are touching. If you want a definitive routine, ask Birdies customer service for the care guidance specific to the Tan Openweave finish before you wear them for the first time.
The price and value question
The catalog lists The Starling 20 in Tan Openweave at USD 120.00, compared with a catalog comparison price of USD 160.00. That is a meaningful gap, and it is worth asking whether the openweave version earns its place in your closet. The case for it is seasonal: if you will wear a breathable loafer regularly through spring and summer, the cost per wear is easy to justify. The case against it is overlap: if you already own a tan or neutral loafer you love, this pair fills a narrower warm-weather slot rather than replacing an everyday shoe.
One practical note: the openweave construction is the reason to buy this pair, not a detail to overlook. If you are comparing it with a solid raffia or leather Starling, choose based on whether breathability or durability matters more for the way you actually dress.


