Two Hummingbirds, two very different finishes
The Hummingbird Mary Jane comes in two finishes that look and feel distinct: a soft Tan multicolored oversized grosgrain fabric and a shimmering Vintage Gold metal leather. Both share the same Barefoot Ballerina foundation—a flexible footbed or sock with full arch support and seven layers of cloud-like comfort—and both use an elastic strap so you can slip in without unbuckling. The choice comes down to texture, adjustability, and how you plan to wear them.
This comparison sticks to what the catalog confirms. Where a detail is not listed, such as specific care instructions or heel height, treat that as a gap in the supplied information rather than a reason to guess.
Material and strap differences that affect daily wear
- The Hummingbird Mary Jane Grosgrain - Tan Multi Stripe: Crafted of vibrantly Tan multicolored oversized grosgrain fabric, this Mary Jane flat is soft to the touch. Grosgrain is a textured woven fabric, so this pair reads more casual and tactile than a smooth leather finish.

The Hummingbird Mary Jane Grosgrain - Tan Multi Stripe - The Hummingbird Mary Jane Grosgrain - Tan Multi Stripe: Its elastic strap makes it easy to wear, so you can slip in and out without unbuckling every time. The elastic is built into the strap itself, so there is no separate buckle adjustment to set.
- The Hummingbird Mary Jane - Vintage Gold Metal Leather: The strap includes hidden elastic, so you can slip in without unbuckling every time. Think of the buckle as an adjuster so you can get a custom fit — set it and forget it. This pair gives you a buckle you can set once for a custom fit, which may suit you if you want more control over strap tension.

The Hummingbird Mary Jane - Vintage Gold Metal Leather - The Hummingbird Mary Jane - Vintage Gold Metal Leather: This silhouette was crafted with our Barefoot Ballerina technology, which includes a completely flexible leather-lined footbed that bends with you as if you are barefoot, but still offers full arch support and seven layers of cloud-like comfort. The leather lining is a distinct feel from the satin lining on the grosgrain pair, and both share the same flexible, cushioned construction.
Sizing and fit: what the catalog tells you
Both styles are available in whole and half sizes from 6 to 11, with the metal leather also offered in size 12 and the grosgrain stopping at 11. If you are normally a 12, the Vintage Gold metal leather is the only one of the two with a confirmed option in your size.
The grosgrain pair has an elastic strap with no separate buckle adjustment listed, while the metal leather pair uses a buckle as an adjuster. If you like to fine-tune strap tension, the metal leather gives you that lever. If you prefer a pull-on feel with nothing to set, the grosgrain is the simpler choice.
Neither product record includes a sizing chart, width options, or advice on sizing up or down. Use your usual Birdies size as a starting point and check the retailer's exchange policy if you are between sizes.
Which Hummingbird fits your wardrobe
- Tan Multi Stripe grosgrain: The multicolored oversized grosgrain is soft to the touch and visually textured. It pairs naturally with casual outfits—think denim, cotton dresses, and relaxed tailoring—where a fabric finish feels at home. The tan base keeps it grounded, while the multicolor stripe adds interest.
- Vintage Gold metal leather: The metallic leather has a shimmer that catches light, making it a stronger choice for dressier occasions or when you want the shoe to be the focal point. The onyx buckle and grosgrain backtab with onyx Birdies logo add contrast. It can also lift a simple outfit, but it is less understated than the grosgrain.
Styling the Tan stripe Mary Jane
Because the grosgrain is a fabric with a multicolored stripe, treat it as a pattern. Let it be the only pattern in your outfit, or echo one of its colors in a bag or scarf. A plain white tee and straight-leg jeans let the texture stand out; a tan linen dress keeps the palette tonal. For a tan stripe Mary Jane outfit, avoid competing prints and let the shoe's soft fabric finish do the talking.
Styling the gold metal leather Mary Jane
Gold metal leather Mary Janes work as a subtle statement piece. They look intentional with an all-black outfit, where the metallic shimmer and onyx buckle provide contrast, and they can also finish a monochrome cream or navy look. Because the finish is metallic, it reads dressier than the grosgrain; save it for occasions where you want a little shine, or use it to elevate a simple everyday outfit.
Care and limitations to know before you buy
The supplied product records do not include care instructions for either style. That means you should not assume a specific cleaning method, protectant, or storage routine based on this comparison. For the grosgrain fabric, treat stains with caution and consider professional cleaning if unsure; for the metal leather, avoid abrasive cleaners that could dull the finish. These are general precautions, not manufacturer instructions.
Also note that neither record lists heel height, weight, or removable footbed details. If those matter to you, check the product page or contact Birdies directly before ordering.
A simple way to decide
Choose the Tan Multi Stripe grosgrain if you want a soft, textured, casual flat with a pull-on elastic strap and no buckle to adjust. Choose the Vintage Gold metal leather if you want a buckle you can set for a custom fit, a leather-lined footbed, a metallic finish for dressier moments, or you wear a size 12. Both share the same flexible, arch-supporting Barefoot Ballerina construction, so the decision comes down to finish, strap preference, and size availability.



